You know I’m critical of the left wing of politics, mainly because of its statism—the persistent belief that the way to improve things is to pass more laws and have the state enforce them on more people. My left-wing friends (I have many, and I love them) want a bigger state, a sphere of coercion. It’s not a good idea.
But my friends on the right wing (I have many, and I love them) are also, these days, opting for statism. Like socialists and social democrats, conservatives and, surprisingly, some supposed liberals want the state to take care of matters that should be private.
Like the left, they began to clamor for the “general will” and to try to control the levers of power that express it. The old idea, predating communism, fascism, and their moderate versions on the left and right, was that most social decisions should be made at the individual, family, religious, and similar levels. The principle was that of my grandmother, born in the 1890s, the last era of horses: “Do what you will, but don’t frighten the horses.” Be an adult and responsible in relation to grand purposes, but otherwise, resolve matters of love, ethics, charity, business, and local affairs yourself.
We have heard a lot from the political right about the terrible threats to “Western civilization.” It began in the 1980s. One of the roots of this is a 1986 book by Samuel Huntington, which theorizes about Islamophobia (“The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order”). I knew Allan Bloom superficially, who, in “The Closing of the American Mind” (1987), raised the fear that distancing from conservative cultural norms was “the end.”
Claims that the “end” is near are proliferating on the right. Laura K. Field published a lucid analysis of the entire group last year, titled “Furious Minds: The Making of the MAGA New Right.” Their fears justify a new state activism, as in the Trump administration.
The new conservative statists say we need a secret police to arrest people who look Mexican in the streets and laws to prevent boys who have become girls from playing sports in high school. It’s similar to communism persecuting businessmen or Nazism persecuting Jews, both justified by childhood fears that have become deadly serious through state coercion.
I just heard about a character named Gad Saad, who, in his book, The Parasitic Mind, shows why—as a dear but misguided friend of mine says—“empathy in politics leads to the collapse of civilization.” In a new book, Suicidal Empathy, Saad attacks the “irrational and maladaptive altruism that has taken over our culture” as a “mental parasite … that leads to a catastrophic miscalibration of moral priorities.”
The problem on both sides is bringing the State into issues that would be better resolved through common sense and local decisions. For example, through responsible Christianity. For example, family and friends. For example, the neighborhood.
Let’s stop shouting and start listening, and stop worrying about the “end” being near. It’s not.
Originally published in Folha de S.Paulo.



















